Prefer to listen? You can hear this article narrated by an AI version of my voice.
Which future problems are already visible, yet belong to no one’s current work?
Imagine a manufacturer that is relying on overtime to keep up with orders. The front-line manager can see that two experienced people are carrying most of the work on a critical machine. The production director can see that every shift is losing time at the same point in the process. The head of the business can see that, if demand keeps growing, the plant will eventually run out of room.
I’ll use manufacturing as the main example throughout because it’s easy to see how the work fits together, whatever industry you’re in. The same principles apply in all industries, whether for example you run a service firm, a retail business, a distribution operation, or a nonprofit.
The manufacturer needs someone to get the team ready for the next busy season, someone to improve the way production works across shifts, and someone to decide when the business needs more capacity. Those are three different assignments. If everyone spends their time getting this week’s orders out the door, the business can have a good year and still lose a year it needed to prepare for growth.
If you’re accountable for a team, you’re a manager
Anyone who is accountable for the work of a team has managerial leadership work to do. That means setting direction, assigning work, coaching people, and holding them accountable for results. A front-line manager may also spend part of the day working alongside the team. As you move up the organization, a greater share of your time needs to go into managerial leadership, and more of that work involves helping other managers lead their own teams.
Think about how an organization grows. One manager can lead a small production team. When the business adds another shift or another line, it may need more front-line managers so each team gets the direction and support it needs. Eventually, someone has to look across those teams and decide how production should work as a whole. If one shift changes the order in which it runs jobs, for example, it may save time on that shift while leaving the next shift without the parts it needs. Someone has to be accountable for how the shifts work together.
The same thing happens when the business grows to the point where decisions about sales, production, staffing, and investment need to be made together. Each function can do its work well and the business can still make commitments it can’t deliver. That’s when you need someone accountable for the result across those functions.
How far ahead does the assignment reach?
Elliott Jaques used the term time span of discretion to help us understand the complexity of a role. To make it practical, ask what is the longest assignment this role is accountable for delivering, using judgment as circumstances change along the way?
Suppose the manufacturer is adding a production line. The front-line manager is accountable for having the team trained and ready to operate it by the start of the busy season. The person accountable for bringing the line into service has to work through equipment choices, financing, installation, staffing, and the effect on customer commitments. Both contribute to the same expansion. The time span of each role comes from the work it is accountable for delivering.
As that time span increases, the nature of the work changes. The front-line manager can see who needs training and whether the team is making progress. The person deciding when to add capacity has to make commitments before knowing exactly what customers will buy, what equipment will cost, or who will be available to run it. They need to make decisions now and keep the work on course as those conditions change.
What Levels 2, 3, and 4 look like in practice
Level 2 is the work of leading a front-line team. At our manufacturer, the assignment is to cross-train enough people to cover critical jobs before the next busy season, while continuing to meet current orders. The manager has to decide who can train whom, how to make time for training, and what to do if an experienced operator is away. In a field service business, the equivalent might be getting a crew ready for the winter rush by making sure the right people are trained, vehicles are ready, and emergency calls can be covered.
Level 3 is the work of leading a function. The production director manages the front-line managers and is accountable for building a production system that can handle the volume expected in two years. The director may need to change how jobs are scheduled, how maintenance is planned, and how work is handed over between shifts. The order matters. Changing the schedule before addressing a recurring equipment failure could simply move the delays from one shift to another. In field service, the equivalent might be building a dispatch system that allows several crews to share capacity across a growing territory.
Level 4 is the work of leading across functions. The head of the manufacturer has to decide how much capacity the business will need over the next several years and how to put it in place. Production may see a case for a new line. Sales may see a market for a different product that calls for different equipment. Finance and HR need to work through what the business can afford and whether it can hire the people it will need. The head of the business has to bring those considerations together and decide what the company will commit to. For a field service business, the equivalent could be deciding whether to enter a new region and aligning customer commitments, recruiting, fleet investment, and operations so the business can serve it reliably.
In a Level 4 organization, the head of the business does this work across the organization. In a Level 5 organization, a vice president may do Level 4 work across several functions within a department. You can learn more about the level of a role by looking at the decisions it has to make than by reading the title on the organization chart.
What changes at Level 5 and beyond?
Many organizations are effectively structured at levels 3 and 4. Level 5 is a natural resting point for many larger businesses and, depending on the nature of the work, can accommodate 2,000 or more employees. The level depends on the complexity of the work the head of the organization must do. Employee numbers give us a sense of scale.
At Level 5, the head of the organization leads an executive team whose members already manage across several functions. Imagine our manufacturer now operates several plants and sells several product lines. An operations executive might be accountable for adding production capacity across the plants. The CEO has to decide which markets and product lines the company will pursue, what kind of production network those choices call for, and how to build the leadership and operating capacity to carry them through. Those decisions shape the assignments of the whole executive team.
At Level 6 and above, consider a group that owns several distinct businesses, each with its own leadership team. Each business has to decide how to compete in its own market. The head of the group has to decide where to commit capital across those businesses, whether to build or acquire a new business, and what capabilities the group will need over time. At the highest levels, those choices can span industries and countries. The most complex organizations can require up to eight levels of work, including the front line, which means seven levels of management.
Can the person handle the work the role requires?
Once you are clear about the work, you can look at what it takes to do it well. I use three fundamental capabilities. First, does the person have the problem-solving capability to handle the complexity of the role? Second, do they have the skills and knowledge to do the work? Third, do they value the work enough to apply themselves to it, including the work of leading people?
A front-line manager may be very good at diagnosing why a shift keeps missing its targets. As a director, that person would have to work out how changes to scheduling, maintenance, training, and handoffs affect several shifts, and in what order those changes should be made. At Level 4, they would have to weigh what those improvements could achieve against other choices the business could make, such as investing in equipment, changing the product mix, or expanding to another site.
Problem-solving capability can mature over time. If you’re considering a front-line manager for a director role, give them a defined assignment that crosses teams, along with the authority and support to carry it out. You’ll learn how they think through the dependencies, bring other managers into the work, and adjust as they learn more. They’ll also get a chance to see whether they enjoy doing that kind of work.
Final Thought
At your next leadership meeting, pick one problem you can already see coming. Ask what outcome the business needs and by when. Then ask what work has to start now, who is accountable for delivering it, and what authority that person needs to act.
In our manufacturing example, training people for the next busy season is an assignment. Deciding when and how to add capacity is another. If the second keeps coming up at leadership meetings, try asking who is expected to bring back a decision, and by what date. You may discover that a problem everyone can see has yet to become someone’s work.
As your business grows, the work it needs from you changes. A Vistage peer advisory group gives you a confidential place to bring a decision you’re wrestling with and work through it with leaders who have faced similar changes. They can help you see how far ahead you need to be working, which decisions call for your involvement, and where your managers are ready to take on more. Just as important, they can help you think through how to make the transition: what to hand over first, what authority and support your managers will need, and how to stay informed as they take on that work. If you’re working through that kind of change, I’d be happy to talk. Learn more about my executive peer groups.


